Homes for Sale in Middleton, WI

Middleton real estate is always in high demand and is highly regarded by home buyers who want direct access to Madison while living in a smaller town setting. Known as “the good neighbor city,” this popular community is located both to the west and to the north of Madison. Middleton is known for its strong sense of community. In fact, Money Magazine recently rated the city as the “#1 best place to live in America," one of many reasons the properties here have become so popular.

Thinking about a condo in Middleton? Check out our comprehensive guide to all Middleton condos for sale. Our condo guide profiles 17 local condo associations with more profiles coming soon!

All Homes for Sale in Middleton, WI

140 Properties Found. Page 1 of 24.
Photo of Listing #1875429
New Listing

3483 Hickory Hill Rd, Middleton

$375,000 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 2,245 Sf

MLS® # 1875429, 2 days, Active

Photo of Listing #1875330
New Listing

3871 Caribou Rd, Middleton

$1,125,000 - 6 Beds, 6 Baths, 7,461 Sf

MLS® # 1875330, 3 days, Active

Photo of Listing #1875243
New Listing

3817 Lynn St, Middleton

$429,900 - 3 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,620 Sf

MLS® # 1875243, 4 days, Offer-Show

Photo of Listing #1875114

3280 Eaton Terr, Middleton

$465,000 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 2,732 Sf

MLS® # 1875114, 8 days, Offer-Show

Photo of Listing #1875004
Open house

Scheduled Open House Open House Date: 2020-01-26 Open House Time: 12:00-2:00

8768 White Coral Way, Middleton

$480,000 - 4 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,695 Sf

MLS® # 1875004, 9 days, Active

Photo of Listing #1874941

6262 Elmwood Ave, Middleton

$419,900 - 4 Beds, 2 Baths, 2,308 Sf

MLS® # 1874941, 10 days, Offer-Show

Just Sold Homes in Middleton

Address Sold Price Sold Date Bed Bath Sqft. Price Per Sqft
L62 Swoboda Rd $179,900 2020-01-23 $
3673 Cardinal Point Tr $633,000 2020-01-17 5 3.50 4164 $152
1043 Rooster Run $460,000 2020-01-17 3 2.50 2738 $168
8715 Horizon Ct $390,000 2020-01-17 4 3.50 3093 $126
7546 Summit Ridge Rd $975,000 2020-01-17 4 4.50 5674 $172
4804 St Annes Dr $175,000 2020-01-15 $
1628 Mayflower Dr $333,500 2020-01-13 4 1.50 1500 $222
3943 Weatherwood Tr $537,700 2020-01-07 5 3.50 3333 $161
7121 Companion Ln $320,000 2020-01-06 4 2.00 2437 $131
L11 Welcome Dr $209,800 2019-12-31 $
6637 Boulder Ln $490,000 2019-12-31 3 3.50 2954 $166
#8 - 3416 Valley Ridge Rd - #8 $160,000 2019-12-30 2 2.00 1235 $130
7202 Nightingale Ln $317,000 2019-12-30 3 3.00 1845 $172
1030 Rooster Run $405,000 2019-12-27 3 2.50 2474 $164
#a - 6247 Charing Cross Ln - #A $99,425 2019-12-20 1 1.00 760 $131
3556 Richie Rd $590,000 2019-12-20 4 4.00 5046 $117
2411 Middleton Beach Rd $600,000 2019-12-20 $
L38 Ox Trail Way $240,000 2019-12-19 $
5029 St Annes Dr $528,323 2019-12-17 5 4.00 3300 $160
3903 Fremont Dr $505,000 2019-12-16 5 3.50 3745 $135

Middleton Inventory & Price Trends

Current Listings

  • With Accepted Offers: 41
  • Without Accepted Offers: 99
  • Total Active Listings: 140
  • % with Accepted Offers: 29%
  • Months of Inventory: 2.8

Sold 01/24/2019 - 01/24/2020

  • Total Sold Listings: 419
  • Highest Sold Price: $1,976,400
  • Lowest Sold Price: $99,425
  • Average Sold Price: $414,234
  • Median Sold Price: $381,544

* Source: IDX Active & Sold Listings

* Property Types: Lots & Acreage, Single Family, Condo

More about Middleton, Wisconsin

Middleton has something to offer everyone. This city is home to the popular Middleton-Cross Plains School District. Middleton offers a great variety of parks and recreational spaces, including the Pheasant Branch Conservancy, the community pool, and the "splash pad" at Lakeview Park, a family favorite on hot summer days. The Pleasant View Golf Course is one of the more popular golf courses in the area. Food and shopping venues range from smaller, family owned businesses in the city's center to a vast array of options at Greenway Station. Middleton is home to the Good Neighbor Festival and the Capital Brewery beer garden, places where friends and neighbors relax on lazy summer days.

Middleton Homes for Sale by Neighborhood

Our handy Middleton real estate guides feature community profiles, current listings, maps, and sales data for twenty Middleton neighborhoods. You can learn more about the many great neighborhoods in Middleton by perusing our subdivision guides below.

Real Estate Near Downtown Middleton

Character and charm define the homes near downtown Middleton. If you like picket fences and wrap-around porches, or an old-fashioned brick home near the center of town, this part of the city is the place for you. Nearby, the Meadows, Middleton Heights, Foxridge, and Parklawn subdivisions are four popular neighborhoods located near the city center. The Stonefield subdivision is located a few blocks further to the southeast, while Middleton Beach is nestled up against Lake Mendota a few blocks to the northeast.  

Real Estate in the Town of Middleton

Drive west on Airport Road and the properties in the Town of Middleton feature many attractive designs built on large lots within the popular Sunset Ridge Elementary attendance area. Enchanted Valley, Prairie Home Estates, and Sunset Ridge Estates are three such neighborhoods located along the western edge of the city. 

Drive to the south and you'll encounter several upscale subdivisions situated along the Old Sauk Road and Mineral Point Road corridors. These include the Cherrywood, Cardinal Point Estates, Pheasant Point, Spruce Hollow, and Sauk Point Estates neighborhoods. Just a little further to the south, the Glaciers End and Noll Valley subdivisions offer more luxury properties built on spacious, private lots. If you're in search of luxury real estate, Middleton offers many neighborhoods for your consideration.

Neighborhoods Near Conservancy Spaces

A surprising number of Middleton properties are nestled up against natural environments and protected conservancies, including the homes in Northlake, located along the eastern edge of the Pheasant Branch Creek Conservancy. Middleton Hills, a "new urbanism" neighborhood featuring prairie-craftsman architecture, is located along the opposite end of the conservancy. Nearby, the Middleton Ridge and Misty Valley subdivisions offer access to the conservancy at Graber Pond.

A Bold New Community

North of Lake Mendota, development is underway at the Community of Bishops Bay. When complete, this new development will feature 7 distinct neighborhoods, 10 community parks, an elementary school, and many more amenities.

Carefree Living

Popular condominium communities include Middleton Conservancy and Bishops Bay. The Middleton Conservancy condos offer units in a unique, natural setting. The condos in Bishops Bay are conveniently situated near one of the most prestigious golf courses in the Madison area.

Middleton Neighborhood Guides

Get even more information on Middleton's neighborhoods by looking at each of our guides. We've included property information, recent sales, neighborhood parks and other information to help you target the right community for your next home.

Looking for reliable information on the Middleton real estate market? Be sure to check out our comprehensive updates on the Middleton single family home and condo markets. We update our reports regularly with reliable data sourced directly from the South Central Wisconsin MLS.

Sign up for email updates