All Homes for Sale in Middleton, WI, $400,000 - $500,000

All Homes for Sale in Middleton, WI, $400,000 - $500,000

19 Properties Found. Page 1 of 4.
Photo of Listing #2002254
New Listing

4305 Waxwing Way, Middleton

$424,000 - 3 Beds, 3 Baths, 1,435 Sf

MLS® # 2002254, 0 days, Offer-No Show

Photo of Listing #2002367
New Listing

1813 Countryside Drive, Middleton

$499,900 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,923 Sf

MLS® # 2002367, 2 days, Offer-No Show

Photo of Listing #2003712
New Listing

7213 Elmwood Avenue, Middleton

$475,000 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,860 Sf

MLS® # 2003712, 3 days, Active

Photo of Listing #2003301
New Listing

L11 Colonial Way, Middleton

$450,000

MLS® # 2003301, 7 days, Active

Photo of Listing #2000350

6919 Belle Fontaine Boulevard, Middleton

$420,000 - 3 Beds, 3 Baths, 1,435 Sf

MLS® # 2000350, 9 days, Offer-No Show

Photo of Listing #2000687

3604 Glenn Lane, Middleton

$479,900 - 4 Beds, 2 Baths, 2,200 Sf

MLS® # 2000687, 22 days, Offer-Show

Just Sold Homes in Middleton

Address Sold Price Sold Date Bed Bath Sqft. Price Per Sqft
7017 University Avenue $431,250 2025-07-18 3 2.00 1974 $218
4321 Waxwing Way $421,000 2025-07-16 3 2.50 1435 $293
7022 Franklin Avenue $450,000 2025-07-14 3 1.00 1200 $375
#120 - 6767 Frank Lloyd Wright Avenue - #120 $450,500 2025-07-11 2 2.00 1343 $335
5806 Taft Street $430,000 2025-07-11 4 1.50 1616 $266
4208 Thrasher Street $465,500 2025-07-11 3 2.00 1675 $278
Lot 10 Blue Cedar Drive $466,000 2025-06-27 $
6911 Prairie Drive $450,000 2025-06-27 4 1.50 1732 $260
#219 - 6767 Frank Lloyd Wright Avenue - #219 $500,000 2025-06-26 2 2.00 1377 $363
6884 Pine Siskin Place $482,000 2025-06-26 3 2.50 1563 $308
6983 Spotted Sandpiper Street $459,400 2025-06-17 3 2.50 1563 $294
6967 Belle Fontaine Boulevard $418,000 2025-06-10 3 2.50 1435 $291
6977 Spotted Sandpiper Street $464,000 2025-05-23 2 2.00 1202 $386
2907 Ravine Drive $455,000 2025-05-23 3 1.50 1344 $339
7615 Terrace Avenue $500,000 2025-05-20 3 2.00 1902 $263
5940 Woodcreek Lane $485,000 2025-05-19 3 3.00 2512 $193
3717 High Road $425,000 2025-05-16 3 2.50 1550 $274
4434 Northern Flicker Road $496,000 2025-05-15 3 2.50 1695 $293
3449 Valley Creek Circle $400,000 2025-05-13 3 2.50 2182 $183
3336 Conservancy Lane $500,000 2025-05-12 2 2.50 1818 $275

Middleton Inventory & Price Trends

Current Listings

  • With Accepted Offers: 4
  • Without Accepted Offers: 8
  • Total Active Listings: 12
  • % with Accepted Offers: 33%
  • Months of Inventory: 1.1

Sold 07/19/2024 - 07/19/2025

  • Total Sold Listings: 89
  • Highest Sold Price: $500,000
  • Lowest Sold Price: $400,000
  • Average Sold Price: $454,491
  • Median Sold Price: $455,416

* Source: IDX Active & Sold Listings

* Property Types: Lots & Acreage, Single Family, Condo

Sign up for email updates