Community of Bishops Bay, Middleton

The homes in Community of Bishops Bay belong to a bold and thoughtfully designed development located just north of Lake Mendota and just south of the Dorn Creek Nature Preserve in Middleton, WI. This meticulously planned community incorporates 7 different neighborhoods, each with a unique theme. A total of 10 parks and a network of trails are connected throughout the development. See our property guide toward the bottom of this page to learn more about the perks available at the Community of Bishops Bay.

View all homes for sale in the Community of Bishops Bay, Middleton, WI below. Remember, you can receive automatic updates when new real estate listings in the Community of Bishops Bay become available. Simply sign up with your email address, and we'll take care of the rest.

Community of Bishops Bay Real Estate Listings

Community of Bishops Bay Real Estate Listings

8 Properties Found. Page 1 of 2.
Photo of Listing #2003620
New Listing

4329 Callaway Court, Middleton

$1,499,000 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 3,632 Sf

MLS® # 2003620, 6 days, Active

Photo of Listing #1993292

4822 Breakers Rock Road, Middleton

$1,599,000 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 4,285 Sf

MLS® # 1993292, 41 days, Pending

Photo of Listing #2000455

4846 St Annes Drive, Middleton

$1,100,000 - 6 Beds, 4 Baths, 4,354 Sf

MLS® # 2000455, 43 days, Offer-Show

Photo of Listing #1997973

4922 Saint Annes Drive, Middleton

$1,575,000 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 4,443 Sf

MLS® # 1997973, 43 days, Active

Photo of Listing #1997916

4422 St Andrews Drive, Middleton

$754,900 - 5 Beds, 4 Baths, 3,494 Sf

MLS® # 1997916, 75 days, Active

Photo of Listing #1993076

4804 Saint Annes Drive, Middleton

$1,499,900 - 6 Beds, 5 Baths, 5,132 Sf

MLS® # 1993076, 97 days, Pending

Community of Bishops Bay Homes Sold

Address Sold Price Sold Date Bed Bath Sqft. Price Per Sqft
4410 St Andrews Drive $610,000 2025-05-29 5 3.00 2366 $258
4417 Blackwolf Run $745,000 2025-01-17 5 3.50 3507 $212
4416 Blackwolf Run $882,500 2024-12-20 5 3.50 3474 $254
5032 St Annes Drive $735,000 2024-11-01 4 3.50 3235 $227
5055 Congressional Hill $700,000 2024-10-23 4 3.50 3278 $214
5034 Congressional Hill $1,085,000 2024-08-05 4 3.50 4012 $270
4427 Back Nine Drive $750,000 2024-08-02 5 3.50 3172 $236
4833 Crystal Downs Way $775,000 2024-07-09 5 3.50 2931 $264

Community of Bishops Bay Real Estate Stats

Current Listings

  • With Accepted Offers: 4
  • Without Accepted Offers: 4
  • Total Active Listings: 8
  • % with Accepted Offers: 50%
  • Months of Inventory: 6.0

Sold 07/09/2024 - 07/09/2025

  • Total Sold Listings: 8
  • Highest Sold Price: $1,085,000
  • Lowest Sold Price: $610,000
  • Average Sold Price: $785,313
  • Median Sold Price: $747,500

* Source: IDX Active & Sold Listings

* Property Types: Lots & Acreage, Single Family, Condo

More about Bishops Bay Community 

The homes in the Community of Bishops Bay are built in harmony with the surrounding natural landscape. The master plan incorporates a number of unique amenities for homeowners. In addition to an extensive network of parks and trails, the plan includes a 9 hole golf course, a working farm, community gardens, orchards, a lake, and open prairie space. The master plan also incorporates a number of community focal points, which include an elementary school, neighborhood center, a library, church, and a senior assisted living center.

Choosing Community of Bishops Bay Real Estate

There is a selection of new construction homes available at a variety of price points. Buildable lots are also available, and buyers can choose their own builder. A broad spectrum of builders is encouraged, thereby adding to the diversity and character of each planned neighborhood. Be sure to bookmark this page and check in often for the latest real estate listings.

Research Other Middleton Neighborhoods

Get specifics on each part of town, and view real estate trends to help you with your property search.

We're here to help you buy or build a home in Middleton's Community of Bishops Bay. Contact us 24/7 and let us know how we can help you. We're happy to introduce you to the many neighborhoods and amenities that are under development at Bishops Bay.

Sign up for email updates