All Homes for Sale in New Glarus, WI, $400,000 - $500,000

All Homes for Sale in New Glarus, WI, $400,000 - $500,000

6 Properties Found. Page 1 of 1.
Photo of Listing #2033078

116 Valle Tell Drive, New Glarus

$479,900 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,920 Sf

MLS® # 2033078, 17 days, Active

Photo of Listing #2024143

613 Windlach Street, New Glarus

$475,000 - 4 Beds, 4 Baths, 2,719 Sf

MLS® # 2024143, 121 days, Offer-Show

Photo of Listing #2024709

619 12th Avenue, New Glarus

$438,000 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 2,003 Sf

MLS® # 2024709, 110 days, Offer-Show

Photo of Listing #2031309

419 5th Avenue, New Glarus

$429,000 - 3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,900 Sf

MLS® # 2031309, 42 days, Offer-Show

Photo of Listing #2029480

167 Valle Tell Drive, New Glarus

$414,000 - 3 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,347 Sf

MLS® # 2029480, 67 days, Active

Photo of Listing #2028154

167 Valle Tell Drive, New Glarus

$414,000 - 3 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,347 Sf

MLS® # 2028154, 83 days, Active

Recent Sales in New Glarus

Address Sold Price Sold Date Bed Bath Sqft. Price Per Sqft
413 8th Street $405,000 2026-08-10 3 2.00 1732 $234
325 Heidi Court $444,000 2026-08-07 4 3.00 2092 $212
112 Valle Tell Drive $500,000 2026-07-13 4 2.50 2610 $192
913 10th Avenue $425,000 2026-06-17 3 2.00 2142 $198
518 2nd Avenue $415,000 2026-06-08 4 1.50 1651 $251
35 Ac Hustad Valley Road $400,000 2026-04-15 $
1301 2nd Street $422,450 2026-01-05 4 1.50 2404 $176
N8122 Marty Road $460,000 2025-12-05 3 1.50 2632 $175
186 Valle Tell Drive $430,000 2025-12-03 3 3.00 2260 $190

The New Glarus Real Estate Market

Current Listings

  • With Accepted Offers: 3
  • Without Accepted Offers: 3
  • Total Active Listings: 6
  • % with Accepted Offers: 50%
  • Months of Inventory: 4.0

Sold 10/06/2025 - 10/06/2026

  • Total Sold Listings: 9
  • Highest Sold Price: $500,000
  • Lowest Sold Price: $400,000
  • Average Sold Price: $433,494
  • Median Sold Price: $425,000

* Source: IDX Active & Sold Listings

* Property Types: , Lots & Acreage, Single Family, Business/Comm, Condo, Multi Family

Sign up for email updates